I'm very surprised you want the american square look for your car, I'd love to have the european look for mine I could do the conversion easy enough but can't afford to get my car painted right now. If my fenders were in better condition I'd offer to trade you everything you needed, don't know how much shipping would be though. You should try doing that with someone on a north american forum like vwvortex, or try my local one www.vwdov.ca , you'll find most people here want your european stuff

these guys have fenders etc. for american rabbits http://www.bowwow.ca/index.htm

also, they get a lot of their body panels from this danish company, so you might be able to get them a lot closer to home
http://www.autonordic.dk/

good luck